← Research library

AI shopping assistants and holiday discovery: what retail marketers should prepare

AI-assisted research. This note was prepared with the assistance of AI tools. It may contain errors and is not professional advice. See our Legal Disclosures.

AI assistants may become a common place for shoppers to start their research, and gift shopping is full of the questions they are built to handle. We expect more holiday product research to begin in a conversation rather than a search box or a store aisle, and retailers have only a few weeks left to prepare for it.

Retailers cannot control how an assistant answers. They can improve the information it draws on, and that work pays off in search and marketplaces too.

Why gift questions suit assistants

Gift questions are rarely about a single product. They describe a person, a budget, and a deadline. A shopper might ask for "a good gift for a ten-year-old who likes science" or "something that will arrive before the 20th".

A keyword search handles these poorly. A conversational assistant is designed to take the whole question at once.

To answer well, an assistant has to match a product to a recipient, compare options on the attributes the shopper named, and check whether the item can arrive in time. Each of those steps depends on structured, accurate product information. If your data does not say a product suits ages eight to 12, an assistant has to guess, and it may simply recommend a product whose data does say so.

That is the core mechanism we want retail marketers to keep in mind. Assistants tend to favor what they can verify. Clear, consistent facts give them something to verify.

We think this is also why shortcuts that target ranking signals are likely to help less here. An assistant composing an answer is trying to satisfy the shopper's constraints, not match a keyword. Data that states those constraints plainly is the asset.

What assistants are likely to need

We think five kinds of information matter most for holiday questions. None of them is new, but several are often incomplete in product data because they live in merchandisers' heads or on scattered help pages.

  • Gift attributes: age ranges, interests, occasions, and recipient types.
  • Comparable specifications: battery life, size, materials, and compatibility, stated the same way across a category.
  • Shipping facts: current shipping times, order cutoff dates, and pickup options.
  • Gift-friendly policies: gift receipts, extended return windows, and gift wrapping, stated plainly.
  • Honest descriptions: copy that explains who a product suits and who it does not, alongside genuine reviews.

The last item deserves emphasis. Say a description notes that a toy suits children who already enjoy building sets. That is more useful to an assistant, and to a shopper, than calling it perfect for everyone.

A September to November method

The work is manageable if you focus on the products that matter most and sequence it sensibly. This is the order we recommend.

  1. Enrich gift attributes for your top holiday products. An agent can propose attributes from existing descriptions, and merchandisers can approve or correct them in batches.
  2. Publish holiday policies early, in plain language, on clearly structured pages that do not change URL each year.
  3. Write gift guide content that answers real questions by recipient, budget, and interest, with accurate product information. See Structuring Content for Answer Engines.
  4. Keep feeds current as prices, promotions, and stock change through the season, and make the feed the source the site renders from. See Product Feeds Are the New Landing Pages.
  5. Track presence by sampling common gift questions in the assistants your shoppers use, weekly through the season.

Consider a hypothetical retailer with 2,000 active products. Starting with the 50 products it expects to drive the most holiday revenue keeps the attribute work to something a merchandiser can review in a few sessions. It can extend to the next tier once the process works.

What to measure

Presence in assistant answers is hard to measure precisely, and we would treat any single number with caution. Answers vary between sessions and over time, so a repeated sample tells you more than any one check.

We recommend a fixed set of gift questions, written the way shoppers phrase them, run on a regular schedule. For each answer, record whether your products appear, whether the facts stated about them are correct, and whether a competitor appears instead. Over a season, the trend matters more than any week's result. Our post on measuring share of answer describes how to set this up.

Accuracy may matter more than presence. An assistant that recommends your product with the wrong price or an outdated shipping cutoff can create a worse experience than not mentioning it at all. Treat factual errors about your products as a priority signal that your source data needs work.

When you find an error, trace it to its source before fixing it. The wrong fact may come from your feed, an old help page, a marketplace listing, or a third-party review. Fixing the page a shopper sees while the stale source stays live tends to bring the error back. Keep a short log of each error, where it came from, and when it was corrected, so the team can see which sources cause the most trouble.

Avoid shortcuts

Mass-producing thin gift guide pages, or stuffing product titles with gift keywords, can look like a quick way to show up in more answers. We expect these approaches to perform poorly, frustrate shoppers who land on them, and reduce trust in your content over time.

Fewer, useful pages are a better investment. A single gift guide for a recipient type, with accurate attributes and honest notes on fit, gives an assistant more to work with than a dozen near-duplicates.

Plan for assistants that act

Some assistants are moving beyond recommendations toward preparing carts or completing purchases for shoppers. We do not know how widely this will be used this season, and capabilities will vary. It is still worth checking how your store behaves if an assistant is involved.

Test whether your checkout, promotion codes, and policies work as intended when an order is started outside your own pages. Talk with your commerce platform about the approaches it supports, and confirm any disclosure or consumer protection questions with counsel. We cover the wider pattern in Agentic Commerce.

The question we are studying next is how assistants weigh conflicting facts, such as a price in a feed that differs from the price on a page. Our working hypothesis is that consistency across sources matters as much as completeness, and we plan to test it after the holiday season.

How to apply this: pick your top 50 holiday products and add recipient, age, interest, and occasion attributes to each, approved by merchandisers. Then sample 10 common gift questions in the assistants your shoppers use, weekly, and record whether you appear and whether the facts are right.

Related research

Put this research to work

Marketix turns these patterns into software: agents, automated workflows, and a hub that keeps people in control. Sign up for early access.